Top of Tampa

Tampa / Guides / Colombian
The Guide · Colombian

Best Colombian Restaurants in Tampa Bay (2026)

Seven restaurants across Tampa. Compare neighborhoods, price tiers and what to order, then read the full reviews.

Rafael Dominguez
By Rafael Dominguez Staff Writer · Top of Tampa · Updated October 2026 · How the score is built
Best Colombian Restaurants in Tampa Bay (2026)
THE TAMPA DINING GUIDES 7 restaurants
Compare all 7 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 La Pequeña ColombiaTampa$$6.2Burger
02 Cali Viejo RestaurantBrandon$$Paisa
03 Mi Carreta Restaurant & BakerySt. Petersburg$$Bandeja paisa
04 Antojitos Latin CravingsTampa$Ajiaco
05 LA POLLERA COLORADA CLEARWATERClearwater$$Bandeja Paisa con Entrana
06 El Cafetal Bakery and RestaurantTampa$$Empanadas
07 Heights PizzaTampa$Cheese pizza

7 restaurants · In guide order

1 La Pequeña Colombia Yelp

La Pequeña Colombia

Colombian · Tampa · $$
Insider Score6.2

The name promises Colombia, but the signature list here runs burgers, fries, and milkshakes rather than bandeja paisa or arepas. It fits a casual American lunch or dinner order, priced low and built for a quick counter stop, but nothing in the record points to Colombian cooking. Diners hunting the region's Colombian canon should look elsewhere on this list.

What to orderBurgerFriesMilkshake Call Directions
Full review & visiting detailsRead the full review & visiting details

Colombian counter with an American side door

Burger

A Colombian-style burger built for the same counter that turns out tostones and platters, worth ordering alongside the rest of the menu rather than settling for it alone.

Fries

The fries round out the burger order and are the plain, reliable side to pair with a Colombian plate here.

Milkshake

The milkshake closes the counter meal out with something cold and sweet after a plate built around Colombian staples.

La Pequena Colombia lists a burger, fries, and a milkshake alongside its Colombian menu, and that pairing tells most of the story. This is a counter built for a neighborhood that wants tostones de carne y pollo, the fried green plantain stacked with shredded beef or chicken, on the same order as a griddled burger for the table member who wants something plainer. Service reads as quick, the kind of counter where orders move and tables turn without much wait, which fits a room built for casual lunch and dinner rather than a sit-down occasion. The tostones appear to be the dish that pulls people in the door, plantain doing the work a bun would do elsewhere, and the fact that it shares a menu with fries and a milkshake says this kitchen is not trying to draw a line between Colombian home cooking and the American short-order plate.

That combination is common across Tampa's Colombian and Latin American counters, which often run a hybrid menu to serve both homesick regulars and neighbors who wander in without much frame of reference. The restaurant sits next to LCPX cafe, suggesting a small cluster of related counters rather than an isolated storefront, and the connection matters for anyone building a stop that covers both a meal and a coffee. Pricing lands in the moderate range, consistent with a counter serving plantain, beef, and chicken plates alongside diner-style sides rather than a full-service Colombian restaurant with table service and a wine list. The staff gets credited for being attentive despite the pace, which matters in a counter format where the person taking the order is often the only face a customer sees.

This is not the deviled crab counter, the Cuban sandwich window, or the cafeteria tradition that defines Ybor and West Tampa. It is Colombian food finding its own counter format in Tampa, plainly, without dressing itself up as anything else, serving a burger and a tostada with the same straightforward hand.

Map showing La Pequeña Colombia© OpenStreetMap
Address6312 N Armenia Ave
Tampa, FL, 33604
Insider tip

Order the tostones de carne y pollo first and treat the burger and fries as the backup plate for anyone at the table who wants something plainer. The counter moves fast, so decide before reaching the register.

2 Cali Viejo Restaurant Yelp

Cali Viejo Restaurant

Latin American · Brandon · $$

Bandeja paisa here means the full plate: rice, beans, ground beef, chicharron, arepa, and a fried egg, and it is what regulars order first. The room in Brandon runs warm and unhurried, with counter seating and service that first-timers to Colombian food seem to leave impressed by. It works for a family table or someone trying the cuisine for the first time.

What to orderPaisaBandeja paisaArepas Call Directions Scored from the full review record 436 E Brandon Blvd, Brandon, FL 33511 · (813) 685-3715
3 Mi Carreta Restaurant & Bakery Yelp

Mi Carreta Restaurant & Bakery

Colombian · St. Petersburg · $$

The fried pork cutlet gets ordered alongside the bandeja paisa here, and both hold up on repeat visits, per regulars who treat this St. Petersburg room as a lunch standby. The space has been updated to feel more open, and it draws colleagues and families equally. A second location closer to some diners has not pulled loyalty away from the original.

What to orderBandeja paisaFried pork cutletArepas Call Directions Scored from the full review record 2705 54th Ave N, Ste 14, St. Petersburg, FL 33714 · (727) 575-7929
4 Antojitos Latin Cravings Yelp

Antojitos Latin Cravings

Colombian · Tampa · $

Ajiaco, the chicken and potato soup thickened with guascas, is the draw on cold days, and the bakery case beside it holds empanadas and pastries worth a look on the way out. This West Tampa spot on the low end of the price scale also runs a breakfast service, with Cuban toast alongside eggs, showing the crossover common in Tampa's Latin corridor.

What to orderAjiacoEmpanadaArepa Call Directions Scored from the full review record 2302 W Columbus Dr, Tampa, FL 33607 · (813) 251-9688
5 LA POLLERA COLORADA CLEARWATER Yelp

LA POLLERA COLORADA CLEARWATER

Colombian · Clearwater · $$

Bandeja Paisa con Entraña, the classic plate built around skirt steak, arrives generous, with beans and plantains doing the supporting work. This Clearwater room seats a crowd without feeling cramped, ceiling fans overhead, a bar in the corner, and service that keeps pace even late into the night. It is a straightforward Colombian dinner spot, not a beach-strip tourist stop.

What to orderBandeja Paisa con EntranaBeansPlantains Call Directions Scored from the full review record 1226 S Highland Ave, Clearwater, FL 33756 · (727) 210-1908
6 El Cafetal Bakery and Restaurant Yelp

El Cafetal Bakery and Restaurant

Colombian · Tampa · $$

Empanadas are the reason this Tampa bakery and restaurant built its name, and the arepas and pan de queso that follow hold the same standard. It sits in a strip plaza on a side of town some diners rarely cross to, but the bakery case rewards the drive on its own. Over a decade in, it functions as both a to-go bakery stop and a sit-down lunch room.

What to orderEmpanadasArepasPan de queso Call Directions Scored from the full review record 4304 S Dale Mabry Hwy, Ste 1, Tampa, FL 33611 · (813) 898-0813
7 Heights Pizza Yelp

Heights Pizza

Pizza · Tampa · $

Cheese and meat pizza by the slice, plus fried sides, are the whole menu here, and the record on this Tampa counter spot is split. Some praise the cheese-heavy pies for a budget lunch; others call the same slices among the worst they have had nearby, with fried sides adding little. It is a pizza counter, not a stop for Colombian food, and belongs on a different list entirely.

What to orderCheese pizzaMeat pizzaFried sides Call Directions Scored from the full review record 7504 N Florida Ave, Seminole Heights, Tampa, FL 33604 · (813) 644-7130
What to know before choosing a restaurant

Best Colombian Restaurants in Tampa Bay: 1. La Pequeña Colombia · 2. Cali Viejo Restaurant · 3. Mi Carreta Restaurant & Bakery · 4. Antojitos Latin Cravings · 5. LA POLLERA COLORADA CLEARWATER. Addresses, prices and what to order.

Colombian kitchens run through Tampa and its suburbs the same way Cuban and Puerto Rican ones do, distinct traditions with their own dishes and their own rooms. This guide covers bandeja paisa, ajiaco, and arepas from West Tampa to Brandon to Clearwater, with two entries that do not belong in a Colombian roster at all.

Frequently asked

What is the best Colombian restaurant near me in Tampa Bay?
It depends on which side of the bay you are on. West Tampa and central Tampa have strong options like Antojitos Latin Cravings and El Cafetal Bakery and Restaurant, Brandon has Cali Viejo Restaurant, and St. Petersburg has Mi Carreta. Clearwater is covered by La Pollera Colorada. Check the Insider Score on each listing to compare within your area.
What is bandeja paisa?
It is Colombia's signature combination plate: rice, red beans, ground beef, chicharron, a fried egg, arepa, and often plantain and avocado on the side. Several restaurants in this guide, including Cali Viejo, Mi Carreta, and La Pollera Colorada, build their reputation around it.
Are all these restaurants actually Colombian food?
No. Two entries on this list, La Pequeña Colombia and Heights Pizza, serve American burgers and pizza rather than Colombian dishes despite appearing in a Colombian search. We include them here for transparency about what a broad search surfaces, not as recommendations for the cuisine.
How are these restaurants ranked, and does anyone pay to be listed?
Ranking is based on the Insider Score, a rating built from the public review record for each restaurant. No restaurant pays for placement or a higher score on this list.
ƒ

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Rafael Dominguez
Staff Writer · Top of Tampa

Ybor City and Heritage Editor. West Tampa Cuban-Sicilian family; great-grandparents rolled cigars. Names the dish properly first, then tells you plainly who still makes it right. Bilingual in Spanish.

Five rooms, every Friday.

The new opening, the sleeper the score just flagged, and the one room worth booking this week. Free.

Get the Tip Sheet →