Find your Mac and Cheese in St. Petersburg, FL restaurant.
Showing all 12 restaurants in ranking order.
About Mac and Cheese in St. Petersburg, FL restaurants in St. Petersburg, FL
St. Petersburg does not have a mac and cheese scene so much as a handful of kitchens that treat it as a side worth caring about. This list runs from Central Avenue lunch counters to the pier, sorted by who actually gets the dish right, not just who lists it.
Compare all 12 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
Bodega on Central is a Cuban sandwich stop first, built around a pressed loaf loaded with ham, roast pork, and pickles, plus ropa vieja and black beans and rice on the steam line. Mac and cheese shows up as a side here, not the draw, but portions run large and prices stay low. Go for the Cuban, let the mac and cheese ride along.
What to order
Cuban sandwich, Ropa vieja, Black beans and rice
1180 Central Ave, St Petersburg, FL 33705 · (727) 623-0942
The Urban Stillhouse keeps its mac and cheese in the same lane as its burger and steak: straightforward, no fuss, built for a group that wants something to share without ordering off a tasting menu. It reads as a side dish done seriously rather than a centerpiece, which fits a room built for casual weeknight dinners more than special occasions.
The Urban Stillhouse deals in the fundamentals of American eating: burger, steak, mac and cheese, done without the need to dress any of them up further. That restraint is the point. In a St. Petersburg dining scene increasingly stocked with rooms chasing a concept, this one commits to the register of a good local kitchen that wants to feed groups well and get the order right the first time. The burger is the anchor and reads as the dish regulars order on repeat.
Steak and mac and cheese round out a menu built for people who want to eat, not decode a chef's statement. That is not a knock. A kitchen that executes the basics with consistency earns its price tag more honestly than one hiding behind reduction sauces. The drink program deserves separate mention. A whiskey flight and a coconut margarita finished with coconut sugar suggest a bar staff paying attention to detail rather than pouring on autopilot, and knowledgeable service on the floor backs that up.
That combination, a bar that tries and a kitchen that does not overreach, is what makes a room like this durable rather than trendy. The building itself carries some character, with a bar area and interior that lean rustic rather than polished, giving the room a lived-in feel appropriate to its role as a neighborhood standby. St. Petersburg has no shortage of destinations chasing Central Avenue attention; this one reads as content to be the place a family books for a holiday dinner or a group picks because nobody has to negotiate the menu. At upscale pricing, it sits above a burger joint and below a special-occasion steakhouse, which is exactly the gap a lot of Tampa Bay diners are actually looking to fill on a Tuesday or a holiday week.
This is not a room chasing a wine cellar's reputation or a century-old claim. It is judged on whether the burger is cooked right and the mac and cheese has body, and by the record, it clears that bar.
Insider tip
Order the burger and ask the bar to build the whiskey flight or the coconut margarita; the drink program is doing as much work here as the kitchen, and reservations are worth making for weekend groups.
Cassis runs its kitchen around weekend brunch, eggs benedict and burgers leading the ticket, with mac and cheese as a comfort option for the table that wants something heavier than eggs. Service handles large groups well on slow mornings. It is a brunch room that happens to do a solid mac and cheese, not a mac and cheese destination.
What to order
Eggs benedict, Burger, Fish of the day
170 Beach Dr NE, St Petersburg, FL 33701 · (727) 827-2927
COPA leans Afro Latin Caribbean, conch and tostones and cocktails under a live DJ most nights, so mac and cheese here gets the Caribbean treatment rather than the diner version. It works as a side against a menu built for sharing and drinking, in a Downtown St. Petersburg room where the music is as much the point as the plate.
What to order
Conch with conch and tostones, Tiki Taka, Good juju
1047 Central Ave, St. Petersburg, FL 33705 · (727) 623-9199
The Chattaway is a burger house with a shaded outdoor patio, and its mac and cheese plays the classic diner-side role next to a well built, well cooked burger. The room has run for decades on that combination: cold tea, a burger cooked right, sides that do not try to outshine it. Straightforward, no reinvention needed.
The Chattaway runs on a formula that has not needed updating: a burger, a basket of fries, sweet tea, and enough outdoor seating to make the whole thing feel like a cookout with a cash register. The burger is the reason people cross town for it, a diner-style patty served without pretense, and the fries hold up as a real side rather than filler. Sweet tea gets called out often enough to count as a third signature, which says something about a kitchen that treats the basics as worth getting right rather than as an afterthought to a fancier menu. This is American food in the plainest sense, the kind of order-at-the-counter cooking that predates the current wave of smash burgers and brioche buns, and it reads as more honest for it. St.
Petersburg has plenty of rooms chasing a polished plate; this one is not one of them, and it does not need to be. The outdoor seating is the actual draw as much as the food, string lights and picnic tables standing in for a dining room, which puts The Chattaway closer to a backyard party than a restaurant in feel. Pricing stays moderate, which matters, because this is built for repeat visits rather than a special occasion. It works for a family that does not want to negotiate over where to eat, for a first date low on pressure, for anyone who wants a burger without a wait that eats up the afternoon. It is not competing with the smoked mullet houses across the bridge or the Cuban sandwich counters in Ybor.
It is competing with every other casual burger spot in St. Pete, and the tea and the fries are what keep people choosing it over the closer options. The room's whole appeal is that it has not tried to become something else.
Insider tip
Get the burger with the fries and a sweet tea rather than substituting anything; that trio is the order that made the place a regular stop, and the outdoor tables are worth waiting for over a spot inside.
What to order
Burger, Tea, Fries
HoursMon - Thu:11:00 AM - 10:00 PMFri - Sat:11:00 AM - 11:00 PMSun:11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunset Grille is a wings and craft beer bar first, blackened garlic sauce wings the thing people drive for, with mac and cheese sitting on the side menu for the table that wants something besides fried food. Hours have been inconsistent enough that calling ahead is worth doing before making the trip for it specifically.
LALA pairs karaoke and cocktails with a kitchen that takes its comfort sides seriously, duck linguine and calamari the headline dishes but mac and cheese fitting the same register: rich, a step above bar food. Homemade ranch gets mentioned alongside the calamari. Priced fairly for a room built around a night out rather than a quiet dinner.
What to order
Duck linguine, Calamari, Steak
2324 Central Ave, St. Petersburg, FL 33712 · (727) 329-9455
Kristina's Cafe is a diner built on tuna salad plated with potato salad and cottage cheese, and meatloaf under brown gravy, the kind of menu where mac and cheese slots in as a reliable side rather than a showpiece. Portions run generous and prices stay diner-level. It is comfort food without ceremony, hit or miss depending on the day.
What to order
Tuna salad, Meatloaf, Green beans
3590 34th St N, Saint Petersburg, FL 33713 · (727) 526-6673
Skyway Jack's is a breakfast institution built on Mexican omelettes, Hobo soup, and waffles piled with bananas and whipped cream, hearty portions at a low price. It is not a mac and cheese room by trade, but the same throwback diner instinct that makes the waffles work would carry a side of it. Go for breakfast, not dinner.
Skyway Jack's runs on the kind of breakfast math that made diners popular before diners had a name for it: big plates, low prices, no pretense. The Mexican omelette is the order that gets mentioned most, loaded enough that splitting it is a reasonable move, not a cheap one. The Hobo soup is the deeper cut, a hearty, savory bowl that reads like something built to use what the kitchen had on hand rather than something designed for a menu photo. Waffles with whipped cream and bananas round out the case that this is a kitchen comfortable in both the savory and sweet lanes of the breakfast counter, and confident enough not to fuss over either one.
It is the kind of place that earns loyalty by simply doing the same good thing every morning without needing to reinvent it. The price point puts it squarely in the inexpensive tier, which matters in a city where breakfast has gotten expensive fast. This is a room for people who want to eat well before work, not people looking for a scene. Counter service or table service, either way, turnover reads fast given the crowd it draws, and the room clearly leans into being a fixture rather than a destination. For St. Petersburg mornings, Skyway Jack's is less about discovery and more about dependability, and that is precisely the point.
It is the kind of place that earns loyalty by simply doing the same good thing every morning without needing to reinvent it. The price point puts it squarely in the inexpensive tier, which matters in a city where breakfast has gotten expensive fast. This is a room for people who want to eat well before work, not people looking for a scene. Counter service or table service, either way, turnover reads fast given the crowd it draws, and the room clearly leans into being a fixture rather than a destination.
Insider tip
Go for the Mexican omelette if hungry, split it if not, and save room for the waffles since the portions run large across the board.
What to order
Mexican omelette, Hobo soup, Waffles with whipped cream and bananas
Oak & Stone runs pizza and brunch for groups, with bottomless mimosas timed to a 45 minute pour and a happy hour built for a crowd trickling in over time. Mac and cheese fits the appetizer lineup here, a side to round out a table full of pizza rather than the reason to book it. Built for volume, not quiet.
What to order
Pizza, Brunch, Appetizers
199 Central Ave, Saint Petersburg, FL 33701 · (727) 565-4064
Teak sits at the end of the St. Petersburg pier with harbor views that do the heavy lifting, pan seared fish and grilled steak the entrees people order for the setting. Mac and cheese would be a side note against that view, not the reason to book a table. Worth it for date night, not for the comfort food.
LUMA operates inside a beach resort, coffee, cocktails, and lunch built around guests who never leave the property, which puts mac and cheese in the category of a resort menu side rather than a neighborhood kitchen's signature. The tiki bar and cabanas are the draw. Treat it as a stay-here convenience, not a trip across town for the dish.
Mac and Cheese in St. Petersburg, FL restaurant questions, answered.
What is the best mac and cheese near me in St. Petersburg?
It depends which part of the city you are in. Central Avenue and Downtown have the highest concentration on this list, from Bodega on Central to COPA, while the pier and beach resorts cover the waterfront end. Each entry here was ranked by its Insider Score, and no restaurant paid to be included.
Is mac and cheese usually a main dish or a side in St. Petersburg restaurants?
Almost always a side. None of the rooms on this list build their identity around mac and cheese specifically. It shows up alongside burgers, wings, pizza, or brunch plates, which is why the list also tells you what each kitchen is actually known for.
Are these restaurants ranked by paid placement?
No. Ranking comes from each restaurant's Insider Score, a measure built from the public review record. No restaurant pays to appear on this list or to rank higher on it.
Which of these spots is best for a group?
Oak & Stone, COPA, and Cassis are built for groups, with happy hour pricing, live music, or brunch service designed to handle a table that fills in over time. The Urban Stillhouse also handles a crowd comfortably without needing a reservation.
The data first, then the verdict
We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →
Staff Writer. Grew up bussing tables near the sponge docks and keeps score across the bridges: a room has to beat what is already on her side of the water to earn the drive. Leads with the practical fact.
A new place to try.
The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.