Tampa / Guides / Where to Eat the Best Italian in St. Petersburg, FL

Where to Eat the Best Italian in St. Petersburg, FL.

7 restaurants, what to order, and the details to help you choose your next meal.

Where to Eat the Best Italian in St. Petersburg, FL (2026)
7 restaurants · 1 areaCompare the restaurants

Find your Where to Eat the Best Italian in St. Petersburg, FL restaurant.

Showing all 7 restaurants in ranking order.

About Where to Eat the Best Italian in St. Petersburg, FL restaurants in St. Petersburg, FL

St. Petersburg's Italian scene runs from Central Avenue tasting rooms to neighborhood pizza counters that have no interest in being anything but good. This list covers both ends: the special-occasion tables and the places that earn a weekly order.

Compare all 7 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 Slice of The BurgSt. Petersburg$$Margarita Pizza
02 Gratzzi Italian GrilleSt. Petersburg$$Pasta
03 Original Flavor 1889St. Petersburg$$Pizza
04 Taverna CostaleSt. Petersburg$$$Pasta
05 Sauvignon Wine Locker & American TrattoriaSt. Petersburg$$$Caesar salad
06 Astra Pizza & SubsSt. Petersburg$Pizza
07 Bruno’s PizzeriaSt. PetersburgPepperoni pizza

7 restaurants · In guide order

01

Slice of The Burg

Pizza · St. Petersburg · $$Back to filters

Slice of The BurgYelp

The Margarita Pizza comes out thin and properly charred, not the doughy version too many counters default to. The Vegetarian Pizza gets the same treatment, and Tiramisu closes things out for anyone who ordered dessert alongside dinner. The room stays clean and the counter service moves fast, which makes it an easy weeknight stop rather than an event.

What to order

Margarita Pizza, Tiramisu, Vegetarian Pizza

10484 Roosevelt Blvd N, St Petersburg, FL 33716 · (727) 576-8272

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
Advertisement
02

Gratzzi Italian Grille

Italian · St. Petersburg · $$Back to filters

Gratzzi Italian GrilleYelp

Pasta and risotto anchor a menu built for occasions, in a downtown room small enough that it fills up fast even with a reservation. Tiramisu is the standard closer. The space runs intimate rather than sprawling, better suited to a birthday dinner or a date than a large group looking to spread out.

What to order

Pasta, Risotto, Tiramisu

211 2nd St S, Saint Petersburg, FL 33701 · (727) 623-9037

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
03

Original Flavor 1889

Italian · St. Petersburg · $$Back to filters

Original Flavor 1889Yelp

The pizza comes out of a 750 degree oven and bakes in under three minutes, which is what gives the crust its char and snap. Meatballs and focaccia round out the order, and the wood-fired style extends to pies finished with pesto or hot honey. It draws a casual crowd built for splitting plates among friends.

What to order

Pizza, Meatballs, Focaccia

409 Central Ave, St. Petersburg, FL 33701 · (727) 873-7139

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
04

Taverna Costale

Bars · St. Petersburg · $$$Back to filters

Taverna CostaleYelp

Pasta dishes come out cooked properly across the board, and the appetizers get called out as often as the mains. The house wine list backs a room set up for celebrations, with a dining space nice enough for a birthday party of five and casual enough for a coworker lunch. Price runs a notch above the neighborhood pizza counters.

What to order

Pasta, Appetizers, House wine

200 Central Ave, Ste 165, St. Petersburg, FL 33701 · (727) 954-3863

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
05

Sauvignon Wine Locker & American Trattoria

Wine Bars · St. Petersburg · $$$Back to filters

Sauvignon Wine Locker & American TrattoriaYelp

Reached through an alley and up a flight of stairs on Central Avenue, this trattoria pairs a deep wine list with dishes like Caesar salad and lamb chops. Execution has been inconsistent according to the record, with some visits landing the lamb chops and salad well and others finding them off. The room and the view over Central Avenue are the draw regardless.

What to order

Caesar salad, Lamb chops, Wine selection

241 Central Ave, St. Petersburg, FL 33701 · (727) 827-7896

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
06

Astra Pizza & Subs

Pizza · St. Petersburg · $Back to filters

Astra Pizza & SubsYelp

A locally owned counter that draws repeat weekly orders, Astra runs on consistency rather than flash. The pizza uses ingredients diners describe as noticeably fresher than the chain standard nearby, and the subs and salad round out a menu built for regulars. Service stays friendly at a price point that makes the weekly order easy to justify.

What to order

Pizza, Subs, Salad

2915 16th St N, St Petersburg, FL 33704 · (727) 824-0709

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
07

Bruno’s Pizzeria

Pizza · St. PetersburgBack to filters

Bruno’s PizzeriaYelp

Everything on the menu is made in house, including a pepperoni pizza that draws repeat orders from a newly opened room. Garlic knots run six for five dollars, and a large pizza lands around twenty, numbers that keep this a neighborhood value pick. A complimentary slice of cheesecake at the end has become part of the routine here.

What to order

Pepperoni pizza, Garlic knots, Cheesecake

7815 38th Ave N, St. Petersburg, FL 33710 · (727) 256-1497

Call Directions Scored from the full review record

Where to Eat the Best Italian in St. Petersburg, FL restaurant questions, answered.

What is the best Italian restaurant near me in St. Petersburg?
It depends on which part of the city and what the occasion calls for. This guide ranks rooms by Insider Score, a measure built from the full review record, not a paid placement. No restaurant on this list pays to appear here.
Which St. Petersburg pizza spot is best for a weekly order?
Astra Pizza & Subs and Slice of The Burg both run as neighborhood counters built for regulars, with consistent quality and fast, friendly service. Original Flavor 1889 and Bruno's Pizzeria are better suited to a sit down dinner with friends.
Where should I go in St. Petersburg for a special occasion Italian dinner?
Gratzzi Italian Grille and Taverna Costale both run intimate rooms built for birthdays and celebrations, with pasta dishes that hold up under a group order. Sauvignon Wine Locker adds a deep wine list and a Central Avenue view for a date-focused evening.
How is the Insider Score determined for these restaurants?
The Insider Score is built from the full public review record for each restaurant, weighing consistency and volume rather than a single rating. It is not influenced by advertising, and no restaurant on this list has paid for its placement or ranking.

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Jenna Kalouris
Staff Writer, Top of Tampa

Staff Writer. Grew up bussing tables near the sponge docks and keeps score across the bridges: a room has to beat what is already on her side of the water to earn the drive. Leads with the practical fact.

A new place to try.

The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.