Tampa / Guides / Italian Spots

The best Italian spots in Tampa.

Ten Tampa Bay Italian restaurants, from Gulfport lasagna to a tableside mozzarella cart, with what to order at each.

The Best Italian Spots in Tampa (2026)
10 restaurants · 5 areasCompare the restaurants

Find your restaurant.

Showing all 10 restaurants in ranking order.

About Italian spots in Tampa

This list covers ten Italian restaurants across Tampa Bay, from Ybor City and Hyde Park to Gulfport, St. Petersburg and St. Pete Beach. The rooms differ a lot: a converted house with a wine room, a modern dining room with a mozzarella cart, a steak-forward spot, a plaza restaurant with a bay-facing patio, and a café with a vegan menu. Each entry names the dishes diners order most and one practical tip. Pia's Trattoria in Gulfport leads, followed by Rocca on West Palm Avenue and OLIVIA on West Swann Avenue.

Compare all 10 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 Pia's TrattoriaGulfport$$9.3Lasagna
02 RoccaTampa$$$8.9Mozzarella cart
03 OLIVIATampa$$$8.7Tableside chicken
04 Noble CrustSt. Petersburg$$8.3Pear and burrata pizza
05 Buona RistoranteSt Pete Beach$$7.9Brussels sprouts
06 Beau & Mo's Italian Eating HouseSaint Petersburg$$$7.6Tomahawk ribeye
07 Casa Santo StefanoTampa$$7.5Chargrilled octopus
08 BellaBrava - St. PetersburgSt. Petersburg$$7.3Black truffle pasta
09 Bella's Italian CaféTampa$$7.2Bolognese lasagna
10 Forbici Modern ItalianTampa$$7.2Cup and Char pizza

10 restaurants · In guide order

01

Pia's Trattoria

Italian · Gulfport · $$ · № 6 on the ListBack to filters

9.3Insider Score
Pia's TrattoriaYelp

A Gulfport house worth booking

Pia's Trattoria sits in a converted house on Beach Boulevard in Gulfport, with a small bar up front, several dining rooms, a wine room and a patio. Diners come for lasagna, caprese salad and tiramisu, and many note that nearly the whole menu can be made gluten free. Gnocchi, chicken and shrimp dishes get steady mentions too. Reservations are widely recommended, and service can run slow on the busiest nights.

Pia's Trattoria turns a former house on Beach Boulevard into a string of dining rooms, with a small bar at the front, a wine room, a couple of private rooms for big parties and patio seating outside. The Tuscan feel comes from candles, exposed stone, beams and plenty of greenery, and diners describe it as a trip away from Florida.

The food earns the setting. Lasagna is the plate named most, with caprese salad, bruschetta, gnocchi, shrimp and chicken close behind, and tiramisu or cannoli to finish. A diner with celiac disease praised a menu that can nearly all be made gluten free, which is rare enough to mention.

The practical side is simple: book ahead. Diners report waits on busy nights and some uneven service, but lunch visits have been seated without a reservation. For a Tampa Bay Italian meal that suits a birthday, an anniversary or a quiet date, this Gulfport address leads the list.

Insider tip

Reservations are strongly advised, since diners report waits on busy evenings and tables fill for birthdays and date nights.

What to order

Lasagna, Caprese salad, Tiramisu

HoursMon - Thu: 4:00 PM - 9:00 PMFri - Sat: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMSun: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Address3054 Beach Blvd S
Saint Petersburg, FL 33707
Call Directions
Map showing Pia's Trattoria© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Lasagna

Often the first plate diners name, baked rich and filling, and a natural match for a glass of wine from the list.

Caprese salad

Served as a starter alongside bruschetta, and diners enjoy sharing both before the main course arrives.

Tiramisu

Finishes many meals here, and some tables add a cannoli when they want a second sweet.

02

Rocca

Italian · Tampa · $$$ · № 10 on the ListBack to filters

8.9Insider Score
RoccaYelp

Mozzarella made tableside

Rocca on West Palm Avenue, beside Armature Works, is a modern dining room where the mozzarella cart comes to the table and the cheese is made in front of diners. Pasta draws the most mentions, including gnocchi and egg yolk ravioli, and the burnt cheesecake is the dessert diners order again. House-made bread, careful cocktails and an extensive wine list round out the meal. The room runs cool, so a sweater helps.

Rocca sits on West Palm Avenue next to Armature Works, and the dining room is deliberately plain: simple updated decor, crisp service and a wine list diners call extensive. The pared-down setting lets the plates lead.

The mozzarella cart is the showpiece, with cheese made tableside and served alongside bread baked in house. Pasta draws the most praise, including gnocchi and an egg yolk ravioli, and starters such as tuna crudo, carpaccio and the little gem salad show up often. Steak and blue crab appear on the table too, and the burnt cheesecake is the dessert diners order again.

A few practical notes help. The room runs cold, so a sweater is wise. Resy tables go quickly, though bar space for a walk-in has worked for solo visitors. Cocktails get as much attention as the kitchen, and staff are happy to suggest the order in which to eat.

Insider tip

Reservations go through Resy and fill up, though one diner found bar space as a walk-in; bring a sweater for the cool room.

What to order

Mozzarella cart, Egg yolk ravioli, Burnt cheesecake

HoursMon - Thu: 5:00 PM - 9:15 PMFri - Sat: 5:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun: 5:00 PM - 9:15 PM
Address323 W Palm Ave
Tampa, FL 33602
Restaurant Reservations Call Directions
Map showing Rocca© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Mozzarella cart

Made tableside and described by diners as the highlight of the evening, and easy to share around the table.

Egg yolk ravioli

A richly filled pasta that diners list among the standouts, alongside the gnocchi.

Burnt cheesecake

The dessert diners mention most often, a fitting close after pasta or steak.

03

OLIVIA

Italian · Tampa · $$$Back to filters

8.7Insider Score
OLIVIAYelp

Polished service, hearty Italian plates

OLIVIA on West Swann Avenue stays busy at dinner and at brunch, and diners return again and again to the polished service. The tableside chicken is the dish named most often, followed by lasagna, short rib pasta and lemon fettuccine with lobster. Starters such as frito misto, goat cheese sformato and garlic bread get praise, and the apple butter torta is the dessert to share. Bar seats make a fair fallback without a reservation.

OLIVIA on West Swann Avenue fills its tables most nights, and the energy reads as confident rather than chaotic. Diners single out the staff more than anything else, from servers who guide the menu to bartenders who make a walk-in Saturday feel planned.

The tableside chicken is the signature, and lasagna, short rib pasta, lemon fettuccine with lobster and a squid ink pasta give the menu range. Starters include frito misto, a goat cheese sformato and garlic bread that diners say should not be skipped. Margherita pizza and a filet show up as well, and the apple butter torta is the dessert most often shared.

Brunch is a second draw, with a family-friendly welcome for guests with small children. Reservations through Resy are the safe route, but the bar has served as a strong plan B for those who arrive without one, even on a packed night.

Insider tip

Reserve through Resy, since busy Saturday nights run full, though diners found good seats and service at the bar when walking in.

What to order

Tableside chicken, Short rib pasta, Apple butter torta

Address3601 W Swann Ave
Tampa, FL 33609
Call Directions
Map showing OLIVIA© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Tableside chicken

Prepared at the table, and the plate diners name most often when asked what to get.

Short rib pasta

A rich pasta that diners pair with starters like garlic bread and frito misto.

Apple butter torta

A dessert diners single out for sharing after a hearty dinner.

04

Noble Crust

Italian · St. Petersburg · $$Back to filters

8.3Insider Score
Noble CrustYelp

Pizza, fried chicken and brunch

Noble Crust on North 4th Street in St. Petersburg runs from brunch through dinner, and the menu moves between pizza, fried chicken and bronzed salmon. Pizza gets the most mentions, with the pear and burrata and the works pizzas named often. Skillet garlic knots, fried green tomatoes with pimento cheese and pork belly, and parmesan truffle fries start the table. Brunch drinks and happy hour also draw diners, though service can lag at busy times.

Noble Crust on North 4th Street in St. Petersburg is an Italian-leaning kitchen that covers a lot of ground. Diners describe a room that feels intimate yet open, with indoor and outdoor seating and an energetic crowd, and the menu shifts easily from brunch to dinner.

Pizza leads the mentions, especially the pear and burrata and the works, and a breakfast pizza turns up at brunch. Skillet garlic knots win strong praise, along with calamari, arancini, fried green tomatoes topped with pimento cheese and pork belly, and parmesan truffle fries. Fried chicken, bronzed salmon and a smash burger give the mains a comfort-food edge, and a chai espresso martini has fans at brunch.

The main caution is pace. Several diners had excellent food but slow or inattentive service on busy days, so plan for a longer visit. Happy hour and weekday lunch are lighter options for those who want the menu without the rush.

Insider tip

Brunch draws many diners here, so reserve ahead or arrive early to avoid slow service at the busiest hours.

What to order

Pear and burrata pizza, Skillet garlic knots, Fried chicken

HoursMon: 4:00 PM - 10:00 PMTue - Thu: 11:30 AM - 10:00 PMFri: 11:30 AM - 12:00 AMSat: 10:00 AM - 12:00 AMSun: 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Address8300 4th St N
Saint Petersburg, FL 33702
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Pear and burrata pizza

Diners call it a favorite among the pizzas and a good one for splitting.

Skillet garlic knots

Tender, stretchy bread that one diner ranked the best garlic bread they had ever eaten.

Fried chicken

A regular order at brunch and dinner, named by diners about as often as the bronzed salmon.

05

Buona Ristorante

Pizza · St Pete Beach · $$Back to filters

7.9Insider Score
Buona RistoranteYelp

Small plaza room, big plates

Buona Ristorante is a small dining room in a Gulf Boulevard shopping plaza on St. Pete Beach, with a back patio that faces the bay. Homemade bread arrives first, then Brussels sprouts with pancetta that diners rave about, and lobster or short rib ravioli. New York style pizza, including the goat cheese pie, and a tiramisu finish are other regular orders. Lunch specials such as gnocchi and chicken parmigiano suit a midday stop.

Buona Ristorante is easy to pass without noticing. It occupies a small space in a Gulf Boulevard strip plaza on St. Pete Beach, with only a handful of tables inside and a back patio that looks across the bay. Diners who find it describe a small but mighty dinner stop.

Homemade bread opens the meal, followed by Brussels sprouts with cherry tomatoes and pancetta that several diners call the star of the night. Lobster ravioli, short rib ravioli, wild mushroom pappardelle and shrimp risotto carry the pasta list, while New York style pizza, including a goat cheese pie, covers the casual side. Calamari arrives with fried vegetables and is sized for sharing, and tiramisu and cannoli close things out.

The room is small, so a wait on a Sunday evening is common, and the staff apologize for it. Lunch specials, such as gnocchi or a chicken parmigiano sandwich, make a lighter, quicker visit.

Insider tip

Tables are few, so expect a wait on busy evenings, and ask about the back patio that faces the bay.

What to order

Brussels sprouts, Lobster ravioli, Goat cheese pizza

HoursMon - Thu: 11:30 AM - 9:30 PMFri - Sat: 11:30 AM - 10:00 PMSun: 11:30 AM - 9:30 PM
Address4705 Gulf Blvd
St. Pete Beach, FL 33706
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Brussels sprouts

Flash-fried with cherry tomatoes and crispy pancetta, and one diner would return for them alone.

Lobster ravioli

A pasta many diners name first, with the short rib ravioli close behind.

Goat cheese pizza

A New York style pie that diners pick from the pizza list.

06

Beau & Mo's Italian Eating House

Italian · Saint Petersburg · $$$ · № 25 on the ListBack to filters

7.6Insider Score
Beau & Mo's Italian Eating HouseYelp

A steak-forward Italian dining room

Beau & Mo's Italian Eating House on 5th Avenue North in St. Petersburg is the steak room on this list, a small, dim space with black and white artwork and Frank Sinatra overhead. The tomahawk ribeye is the headline order, and one diner rated it above what could be grilled at home. French onion mac and cheese, wedge salad, meatballs and cannoli fill out the table. Parking is behind the building, and bar seats can be reserved.

Beau & Mo's Italian Eating House on 5th Avenue North in St. Petersburg is dim, small and styled with black and white artwork, and diners mention Frank Sinatra playing overhead. The mood is romantic, and the staff are described as friendly, quick to greet and ready to explain the menu.

Steak is the main event. The tomahawk ribeye gets the loudest praise, with Tomahawk Tuesday a popular night, and filet, porterhouse and skirt steak are also named. Shrimp and lobster share the menu, and the sides draw attention: French onion mac and cheese, a wedge salad, meatballs and house cannoli. Wine mentions run high among diners.

Practical points are easy. Parking is behind the building, and one pair found that reservations at the bar worked well. Prices run higher, and a few diners noted uneven nights, so this fits a special dinner better than a casual stop. For steak lovers on an Italian list, it is the clear choice.

Insider tip

Parking is available behind the restaurant, and reservations, including at the bar, help on busy dates like birthdays and anniversaries.

What to order

Tomahawk ribeye, French onion mac and cheese, Meatballs

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Sat: 4:30 PM - 9:30 PMSun: Closed
Address2924 5th Ave N
Saint Petersburg, FL 33713
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Tomahawk ribeye

Treated by diners as the headline cut, and Tomahawk Tuesday is when many go for it.

French onion mac and cheese

A rich side that diners name alongside the steak and a wedge salad.

Meatballs

Named among the starters diners recommend, often followed by a cannoli to close.

Advertisement
07

Casa Santo Stefano

Sicilian · Tampa · $$Back to filters

7.5Insider Score
Casa Santo StefanoYelp

Tampa Sicilian cooking in Ybor City

Casa Santo Stefano on North 22nd Street in Ybor City is a large, handsome dining room with an open kitchen, a stainless steel wood-burning grill and a rooftop bar with a cigar lounge. The menu leans on Tampa Sicilian dishes: fresh pasta, lasagna, meatballs and hot honey pizza, plus chargrilled octopus and house-made breads. Tiramisu and cannoli are made in house. Service is attentive, and lunch is an easy way in.

Casa Santo Stefano on North 22nd Street fills a handsome building in Ybor City, with an open kitchen, a stainless steel wood-burning grill and a rooftop bar and cigar lounge. Diners praise the architecture and the staircases, and describe a warm, polished welcome even on busy Friday evenings without a reservation.

The cooking draws on Tampa Sicilian dishes. Fresh pasta, lasagna, meatballs, squid ink pasta and clam pasta share the menu with hot honey pizza, steaks and seafood. Chargrilled octopus has won high praise at lunch, as have the house-made breads, including a rosemary olive oil loaf. Arancini and fried risotto start the table, and tiramisu and cannoli are made in the kitchen.

A few diners report uneven service or dishes that missed, so expectations should be calm on very busy nights. Lunch is a relaxed way to see the room, and the rooftop bar is a good place for a drink before or after dinner.

Insider tip

Busy Friday evenings can run full, so reserve ahead, and allow time to find parking in Ybor City.

What to order

Chargrilled octopus, Lasagna, Tiramisu

HoursDaily: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Address1607 N 22nd St
Tampa, FL 33605
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Chargrilled octopus

One lunch diner called it some of the best chargrilled octopus ever eaten, served with fresh breads.

Lasagna

A baked pasta that diners order at lunch and dinner and mention often among the pasta dishes.

Tiramisu

House-made, and diners finish with it or the cannoli after a long meal.

08

BellaBrava - St. Petersburg

Italian · St. Petersburg · $$Back to filters

7.3Insider Score
BellaBrava - St. PetersburgYelp

Beach Drive pasta and pizza

BellaBrava on Beach Drive Northeast in St. Petersburg has outdoor seating with heaters in cooler weather and a menu that spans pasta, pizza and salads. Black truffle pasta, stuffed gnocchi and goat cheese ravioli are the dishes diners keep recommending, and the hot honey pepperoni pizza has fans too. Trattoria meatballs with polenta start many tables. One diner raised in an Italian household called it a new favorite.

BellaBrava sits on Beach Drive Northeast in St. Petersburg, and its outdoor seating, with heaters in winter, is part of the draw. The menu is wide: pasta, pizza, salads and plates to share, with a casual Italian tone.

Black truffle pasta is the dish diners recommend most, and stuffed gnocchi, goat cheese ravioli, mafaldine and short rib pasta add range. Trattoria meatballs with polenta start many meals, and the bruschetta comes piled high. Hot honey pepperoni pizza is popular, a strawberry burrata salad has fans, and tiramisu is the usual dessert. A diner who grew up in an Italian household called it a standout.

Results vary. A few diners reported off visits and others noted that a sauce carries heat, but several said a return visit went much better. Lunch is busy, and service for anniversaries has drawn warm praise, so a reservation helps on weekends.

Insider tip

Outdoor seating is heated in winter, and one diner noted the sauce carries some heat, so ask about spice.

What to order

Black truffle pasta, Stuffed gnocchi, Hot honey pepperoni pizza

HoursMon - Thu: 11:30 AM - 10:00 PMFri: 11:30 AM - 11:00 PMSat: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PMSun: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Address204 Beach Dr NE
St. Petersburg, FL 33701
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Black truffle pasta

Called amazing by diners and among the most ordered pastas on the menu.

Stuffed gnocchi

Disappeared quickly at one table that paired it with trattoria meatballs and polenta to start.

Hot honey pepperoni pizza

A sweet and spicy pie that diners order for the table.

09

Bella's Italian Café

Italian · Tampa · $$Back to filters

7.2Insider Score
Bella's Italian CaféYelp

SoHo Italian with vegan options

Bella's Italian Café on South Howard Avenue in SoHo, Tampa, serves bolognese lasagna, margherita pizza, chicken dishes and a chopped salad, with a make-it-yours pasta option. A vegan menu, including a vegan chicken parm and pizza, sets it apart from the rest of the list. Bruschetta arrives soon after seating, and tiramisu is a regular finish. Parking and table waits are the common complaints, so plan some extra time.

Bella's Italian Café on South Howard Avenue in SoHo has a neighborhood feel that is relaxed without being overly casual. Diners say the room is intimate and good for date night, and a bartender's recommendation at the bar has turned a lasagna skeptic.

The menu reaches from bolognese lasagna and margherita pizza to a chopped salad, parm dishes and a pasta built from chosen ingredients. Bruschetta arrives soon after seating, lobster and shrimp dishes appear, and tiramisu is a frequent finish. Vegan diners get a full menu here, with a vegan chicken parm and a pizza that one diner called flavorful, which is rare on an Italian list.

Parking and waits are the repeat concerns. One group spent about forty minutes finding a spot and getting a table on a holiday week, and found it worth it. A few diners felt portions or seasoning slipped recently, so arriving early and ordering the signature dishes is the safer plan.

Insider tip

Arrive early on busy nights, since diners report parking trouble and a wait for a table.

What to order

Bolognese lasagna, Chopped salad, Vegan chicken parm

HoursMon - Thu: 11:30 AM - 10:30 PMFri: 11:30 AM - 12:00 AMSat: 3:00 PM - 12:00 AMSun: 3:00 PM - 10:30 PM
Address1413 S Howard Ave
Tampa, FL 33606
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Bolognese lasagna

Won over a diner who is usually wary of lasagna in Florida, on the bartender's advice.

Chopped salad

Diners call it the cafu00e9's well-known salad and order it with parm dishes.

Vegan chicken parm

Surprisingly tasty according to a diner who usually skips plant-based chicken, with a sauce they liked.

10

Forbici Modern Italian

Italian · Tampa · $$Back to filters

7.2Insider Score
Forbici Modern ItalianYelp

Hyde Park pizza and meatballs

Forbici Modern Italian on West Snow Avenue in Hyde Park is a bright, open dining room best known for pizza, both the round Cup and Char and the square Firebird. Meatballs, Calabrian chicken wings and Parmesan truffle fries start the table, and pastas such as pesto with grilled chicken and an eggplant lasagna fill out dinner. Online reservations are easy and recommended for busy weekends and Sunday brunch.

Forbici Modern Italian on West Snow Avenue in Hyde Park is bright and open, with high tops and plenty of seating. Diners mention upbeat music that stays below shouting level, and tables close enough to hear a neighbor, which suits a lively Sunday brunch or a group dinner.

Pizza is the center of the menu. The round Cup and Char and the square Firebird are named most, and sharing both is a common move. Meatballs, shrimp dishes, Calabrian chicken wings and Parmesan truffle fries fill out the starters, while pesto with grilled chicken and an eggplant lasagna cover the pasta side. Fried ravioli appeared as a special and drew praise for its crisp shell and cheese filling.

Service gets high marks from many diners, and online booking is easy. A few felt prices ran high, and busy weekends bring a wait, so a reservation is the sensible move for Sunday brunch or a Friday night.

Insider tip

Book online, since weekends and Sunday brunch fill up, and expect to sit close to neighboring tables.

What to order

Cup and Char pizza, Meatballs, Calabrian chicken wings

HoursMon - Wed: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PMThu: 11:00 AM - 11:00 PMFri: 11:00 AM - 12:00 AMSat: 10:00 AM - 12:00 AMSun: 10:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Address1633 W Snow Ave
Tampa, FL 33606
Call Directions

More about the dishes

Cup and Char pizza

The round pizza diners pair with the square Firebird when sharing at lunch.

Meatballs

Named often by diners as a starter and a good match for the pizzas.

Calabrian chicken wings

A spicy starter that diners order to share before the pizzas arrive.

Italian spot questions, answered.

What is the best Italian restaurant in Tampa?
Pia's Trattoria in Gulfport ranks first on this list. Diners praise the lasagna, caprese salad and tiramisu, the rooms of a converted house on Beach Boulevard, and a menu that can be made gluten free. Rocca in downtown Tampa and OLIVIA in South Tampa follow.
Where can I find good Italian food near me in Tampa?
In Tampa itself, look at Rocca on West Palm Avenue next to Armature Works, OLIVIA on West Swann Avenue, Forbici Modern Italian in Hyde Park, Bella's Italian Café in SoHo, and Casa Santo Stefano in Ybor City. Across the bay, Noble Crust, Beau & Mo's and BellaBrava are in St. Petersburg.
Which Italian restaurant in Tampa Bay has vegan dishes?
Bella's Italian Café on South Howard Avenue in SoHo has a vegan menu, and diners mention its vegan chicken parm and pizza. Pia's Trattoria in Gulfport is the pick for gluten-free diners, since much of its menu can be adapted.
Which Italian spot is best for a steak dinner?
Beau & Mo's Italian Eating House on 5th Avenue North in St. Petersburg is known for its tomahawk ribeye, and diners also like the French onion mac and cheese and the wedge salad. Rocca in Tampa also serves steak alongside its pasta.

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Corinne Ashford
Staff Writer · Top of Tampa

Food Editor. Measures every white-tablecloth room against the standard the old institutions set, and rations her praise so it means something.

A new place to try.

The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.