Find your Seafood Spots in St. Petersburg, FL restaurant.
Showing all 6 restaurants in ranking order.
About Seafood Spots in St. Petersburg, FL restaurants in St. Petersburg, FL
St. Petersburg keeps its seafood in two lanes: dressed-up rooms built for a group occasion, and docks and counters where you eat off paper with a boat view. This list covers both sides of Central Avenue and out toward the water, with one Pinellas smoked-fish institution thrown in because no St. Pete seafood guide is honest without it.
Compare all 6 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
The beef carpaccio and a pastry plate anchor a brunch menu built for parties, and a private room handles groups of ten without crowding the main floor. Service extends to phone orders from out of state, which says something about how the front of house runs. This is the pick for a birthday or an anniversary, not a quick weeknight plate.
What to order
Beef carpaccio, Spicy seafood dish, Pastry plate
400 Beach Dr NE, St. Petersburg, FL 33701 · (727) 258-4222
Arroz con mariscos and a shareable ceviche are the order here, in a Peruvian dining room dressed for date night rather than a beach lunch. It fills fast on weeknights, so reservations matter more than the casual seafood spots on this list. The tiradito gives it range beyond the raw bar, and the room reads as a destination for a dressed-up night rather than a stop on the way somewhere else.
Smoked mullet over red oak put this South Pasadena counter on the map, and the German potato salad and smoked fish spread built the following that keeps returning decades later. It runs as a casual, order-at-the-counter operation, and recent visits describe inconsistency, a cheese-topped burger instead of the classic build, sides missing from to-go orders. Go for the smoked fish itself and treat the rest as a gamble.
Ted Peters built its name on smoked fish over red oak, and that remains the reason to detour off US 19 into South Pasadena. The smoked mullet and mahi are the order that matters, plated whole with German potato salad and onion rings on the side, and they represent the genuine Gulf tradition this stretch of Pinellas is known for. The fish spread, smoked and blended with cream cheese and served with saltines, works as a starter or a meal on its own and shows the same technique in a different form. That said, the room runs a second menu that has nothing to do with smoking fish: a cheeseburger that regulars have watched change over the years, now built with a processed cheese sauce instead of a melted slice, which reads as a cost decision rather than a recipe update.
The German potato salad, warm and vinegar-forward, is consistent enough to anchor a plate even when other sides come up short on a to-go order. This is a walk-up, order-at-the-counter operation with outdoor picnic seating, priced moderately and built for a quick lunch or an early dinner rather than a leisurely sit-down. It draws a mix of longtime South Pasadena regulars and visitors crossing the causeway specifically for the smoked fish, and the room's reputation was built well before smoked fish became a broader Gulf coast trend. The kitchen's consistency seems to dip in the off hours between lunch and dinner, when the fish can taste like it has been sitting, so timing the visit toward a traditional meal window matters more here than at a full-service restaurant.
For the fish itself, the standard holds. For the fried and grilled extras built to round out a family order, the execution is less dependable than it once was, and the burger in particular is not the dish to build the visit around anymore.
Insider tip
Order the smoked mullet or mahi plate and skip the cheeseburger, and go at a standard lunch or dinner hour rather than the mid-afternoon lull, since the smoked fish is the whole reason to make the trip.
What to order
Smoked fish, Cheeseburger, German potato salad
HoursMon - Tue:ClosedWed - Sun:11:30 AM - 7:30 PM
Address1350 Pasadena Ave S South Pasadena, FL 33707
Lobster rolls and mai tais come with a working view of boats on the water, which is the entire point of eating at a dock bar. Outdoor seating handles groups without much fuss, and service gets specific praise by name in the record, a sign of a floor staff that has its rhythm down. It is built for a slow afternoon, not a fast lunch.
The clambo, a house mashup of chowder and gumbo, and a shrimp po boy carry this open-air spot that has held its spot for years. Fried shrimp gets called out as some of the best in town, breaded and cooked properly at a fair price. Service is uneven by account, but the kitchen's output on the fried plates is the reason it keeps a local following.
What to order
Fried shrimp, Shrimp po boy, Clambo
3336 Dr Martin Luther King Jr St N, St. Petersburg, FL 33704 · (727) 895-2526
Grilled fish and fish tacos share the menu with a dollar-oyster happy hour that turns skeptics into regulars fast. Set in St. Petersburg's Art District, the outdoor patio is built for a casual afternoon rather than a special occasion, and street parking is limited enough that arriving early helps. Word of mouth, not marketing, seems to be how most people find it.
What to order
Oysters, Grilled fish, Fish tacos
2060 Central Ave, Saint Petersburg, FL 33712 · (727) 258-7883
Seafood Spots in St. Petersburg, FL restaurant questions, answered.
What is the best seafood restaurant near me in St. Petersburg?
It depends on the occasion. Juno & The Peacock and Aji Ceviche Bar suit a dressed-up night out, while Casual Clam, Trophy Fish, and Tiki Docks Skyway are built for a relaxed meal outdoors. Each entry here is ranked using the Insider Score, which weighs the full review record rather than a handful of comments, and no restaurant pays to be listed.
Is Ted Peters Famous Smoked Fish in Tampa?
No. Ted Peters is in South Pasadena, a separate city across the bay from Tampa. It is part of the Pinellas smoked-fish tradition, not the Tampa restaurant scene, and it should never be filed under Tampa.
Which spots on this list are good for groups?
Juno & The Peacock has a private room for parties of ten, and Tiki Docks Skyway and Casual Clam both handle groups comfortably with outdoor seating. Aji Ceviche Bar works for a smaller group dinner but fills quickly, so reservations are worth making ahead.
How is the Insider Score different from a star rating?
The Insider Score is built from the full pattern of customer feedback for each restaurant, not a single average. It accounts for consistency over time, not just a snapshot of recent reviews. No restaurant on this list, or on Top of Tampa generally, pays for placement or ranking.
The data first, then the verdict
We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →
Staff Writer. Grew up bussing tables near the sponge docks and keeps score across the bridges: a room has to beat what is already on her side of the water to earn the drive. Leads with the practical fact.
A new place to try.
The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.